Asia Scotland Institute https://asiascot.com Inspiring the next generation to engage with Asia Mon, 18 Mar 2024 19:35:49 +0000 en-GB hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 Asia Scotland Institute Inspiring the next generation to engage with Asia false Talk of bromance between Russia and China may be premature https://asiascot.com/publications/talk-of-bromance-between-russia-and-china-may-be-premature Wed, 12 Apr 2023 15:15:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=6981 Looking at events in perspective is always important, as is recalling the historical context within which most things occur. The recent developments between Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping with their meeting in Moscow is no different, hailed by many in the West as an alarming bromance that bodes ill for the future.

It is not the first time that China and the then Soviet Union came together in a shared enmity toward the United States. In 1950 Mao Zedong established an alliance with the Soviet Union against what it regarded as the US-led revival of Japanese imperialism in Asia.  Mao’s resentment of Soviet condescension poisoned the relationship, leading to a split by 1963. In 1971 Richard Nixon created the opening resulting in an agreement aligning the US and China against the Soviet Union. This grew over two decades, ending with the collapse of the Soviet Union and the Chinese massacre of protesters at Tiananmen Square in 1989. With 9/11 both China and Russia supported the US especially in the common fight against fundamental Islamist terrorists, with each country confronted by similar threats. Since then that sense of common purpose has faded especially as Putin’s dreams of rebuilding Russia’s former imperial past has grown. Yet its lamentable performance in Ukraine has weakened perceptions of Russia and heightened Xi’s discomfort of drawing too close to Putin, whatever the external appearances of a bromance between the two might be. Shortly after the Moscow meeting, Xi reached out to the leaders of the five Central Asian republics to convene a summit in Moscow in May.

A few weeks ago, the Asia Scotland Institute hosted Dr Paul Clifford at the Business School of Edinburgh University where he spoke about his book “The China Paradox”. Updated to reflect recent developments, he concludes that his feelings over China are pulled in many directions. Advocating concentrated pressure to make China back off actions that the global community see as crimes against humanity, he stresses the need for widespread collaboration in areas that make sense such as climate change, environmentally sound technology, biotech and AI for medical applications. “I have a deep admiration for China’s remarkable and unanticipated achievements over the last four decades. I not only feel some pride at what has been achieved but also sadness at aspects of the China that is emerging from this long transition.”

On April 4th, our Institute mounts a webinar with Susan Shirk, Chair of the 21st Century China Centre at the School of Global Policy and Strategy at the University of California, San Diego. Her book ‘Overreach, How China Derailed its Peaceful Rise’, has been viewed as “essential reading for everyone concerned with relations between China and the West.” Her conclusion is that “the festering resentment created by hostile US rhetoric and actions, which is then fuelled by CCP propaganda, could become a liability for stabilising the relationship”.

Writing in The Nation, Jake Werner reflects on a path away from great power conflict. He suggests that “Washington is girding for a long-term contest with China and often views the war in Ukraine as an early skirmish in that larger struggle. Beijing views the conflict differently, feeling itself pushed by US hostility to back Putin despite substantial misgivings about his action.”

Maybe any talk of a bromance is premature. Maybe the couple will never make it to the altar.

This article was written by Chairman and founder, Roddy Gow, and originally published on The Scotsman. The original article can be found published here:

https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/talk-of-bromance-between-russia-and-china-may-be-premature-roddy-gow-4098213

]]>
The Alarming Reality of A Ticking Demographic Time Bomb in China and Russia https://asiascot.com/publications/the-alarming-reality-of-a-ticking-demographic-time-bomb Thu, 09 Feb 2023 19:32:45 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=6573 There is a time bomb ticking whose consequences are beginning to be felt. In China and Russia, the hard facts of demography may cause both societies to crash over the next two decades. If the facts are to be believed there are simply not enough people of productive, working age to support the already large population of retirees in both countries. 

Last year a meeting was held in Austin, Texas of the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS). It was noted how people move from one place to another for various reasons – war, persecution, seeking better opportunities, unemployment etc. This migration of people can result in consequences for both the place they left behind and their new place of residence. These consequences can be economic, social and demographic. Against the background of falling populations, these migrants, if productive, should be welcome.

What are the greatest challenges facing global growth in Asia? Are there factors in addition to climate change that we need to consider? With its focus on pan-Asian markets the Asia Scotland Institute feels that any growth depends on marshalling resources, the most important of which are people and confronting the demographic trends in key countries.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and its alliance with China dominate current affairs media coverage. The human and economic costs in Moscow and Kyiv will certainly continue to mount before the conflict ends and the impact on Europe wide energy and global food supplies have generated additional crises. However, there is another element that requires attention which is the concern we should all have about population projections. 

China’s population is shrinking and the impact post Covid with high fatality figures almost certainly makes it appear that projected economic growth may not be achieved and the expectation of achieving continued GDP figures to challenge the US will fail. The view of Dr Paul Clifford will be shared when he speaks in Edinburgh in mid-February about his book The China Paradox as the guest of the Asia Scotland Institute and the Business School of Edinburgh University. Quite simply there will also not be enough people of working age to support the growing numbers of retirees.

Russia, already suffering the consequences of its military action, is also not renewing its numbers. Since 2016, Russia’s death rate has exceeded its birth rate which has been called a demographic crisis by analysts. The nation has an ageing population, with the median age of the country being 40.3 years. In fact, Russia has one of the lowest fertility rates in the world. 

Japan has the second highest percentage of those over the age of 65 at 29%, after Monaco. In Japan the population is shrinking so dramatically that there is a growing realization of the need for action. Reuters reported that its Prime Minister, Fumio Kishida, speaking in their parliament, pledged to take urgent steps to tackle the country’s declining birth rate, saying it was “now or never” for one of the world’s oldest societies. Japan has in recent years been trying to encourage its people to have more children with promises of cash bonuses and better benefits, but it remains one of the most expensive places in the world to raise a child, according to surveys.

Births plunged to a new record low last year, according to official estimates, dropping below 800,000 for the first time – a watershed moment that came eight years earlier than the government had expected. “Our nation is on the cusp of whether it can maintain its societal functions,” Kishida said in a policy speech at the opening of this year’s parliamentary session.

These sorts of statistics represent enormously important factors on countries’ growth prospects and should be considered when assessing threats and opportunities. China and Russia are both unlikely to achieve any of the more aggressive goals envisaged by geo-political experts, which call for a reconsideration of policies by the West when planning to meet probable future threats, both military and economic. We can expect to hear more on these themes when Dr Gerard Lyons launches the Adam Smith series of economic briefings this month.

This could be the future time bomb.

This article was written by Chairman and founder, Roddy Gow, and originally published on The Scotsman. The original article can be found published here: https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/a-ticking-demgraphic-time-bomb-is-about-to-explode-in-china-and-russia-roddy-gow-4015486?itm_source=parsely-api

]]>
Demonstrations around the globe show a generation demanding change https://asiascot.com/publications/demonstrations-around-the-globe-show-a-generation-demanding-change Thu, 05 Jan 2023 12:35:16 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=6505 Hardly a day goes by without news of further uprisings and protests in different parts of the world. Analysing the causes and identity of those involved is made easier by the impact of social networks. Is there a pattern to these upheavals, are there conclusions to be drawn?


Many commentators believe that this is a Generation Z factor where young people who are driven by a sense of outrage at the policies and actions of their governments express their frustration through demonstrating. World Protests: A Study of Key Protest Issues in the 21st Century, issued by researchers from the German think tank Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung (FES) and the Initiative for Policy Dialogue based at Columbia University, both add to a growing body of literature about an era of increasing protests. They concluded that, “we are living through a period of history like the years around 1848, 1917 or 1968 when large numbers of people rebelled against the way things were, demanding change”.

Now there is a much greater knowledge of global events than ever before. Separating facts from lies is critical. As Churchill said, acknowledging Mark Twain, “a lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on”. There are key elements making up the factors at play. The percentage of those in China under 25 is very significant according to the Wilson Centre, compounding the problem that the country’s reproductive rate is too small to support its retirees. In China some Zero Covid restrictions have been lifted indicating a reaction to and concern about the level of protests. Iran has responded differently with the beginning of executions and the likelihood of many more. However, this shows that the protests are being felt.

Despite very repressive reactions to unrest, many of those protesting have united nearly every section of society in Iran and China. The frustrations of Covid imposed lockdowns have added to the universal feeling of liberty being deprived. Some reactions in recent days suggest a slight easing of restrictions in both China and Iran although whether these turn out to be long term remains to be seen. In a context of heavy censorship, China’s protestors have shown eye-catching creativity, for instance by holding blank sheets of paper to signify discontent that they cannot voice explicitly. Carne Ross is the author of The Leaderless Revolution. He has reflected on the protest movements in China and Iran although there have been others driven by growing dissatisfaction with other autocratic governments. He suggests that each of these uprisings is very different and contingent on local circumstances and causes. But the common factor is that they are facilitated by social media – otherwise they would simply not be possible.

Saif Islam of SRM, based in South Africa agrees: “There are multiple reasons for revolt, economic, political or governments relaxing laws. Protestors will want to see how matters develop and use social media to motivate and inform, as in the Arab Spring.” Victoria Schofield, author and expert on Pakistan and the Commonwealth, highlights the energy of Gen X, the younger, often unemployed, members of society who may feel invincible and are deeply frustrated by the slowness of change.

There is a sense that protest movements will evolve. Intervention in Belarus halted them for a time but even in Russia the regime will ultimately collapse if it proves incapable of change.

This article was written by Chairman and founder, Roddy Gow, and originally published on The Scotsman. The original article can be found published here: https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/demonstrations-around-the-globe-show-a-generation-demanding-change-roddy-gow-3973904?amp

]]>
THE CLIMATE CHANGE CHALLENGE – The Asian Perspective https://asiascot.com/publications/the-climate-change-challenge-the-asian-perspective-2 Fri, 29 Oct 2021 08:30:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=1757 Over the coming days, Glasgow will host the largest and most important sequel to the Paris Climate Accords. The hope is that the momentum generated by that meeting can be revived and a return of leadership from the United States be achieved. The Asia Scotland Institute is particularly focused on the actions being taken by the countries of Asia and the extent to which they too may provide a form of leadership in the face of the acute challenges confronting the world.

The facts surrounding Global Warming and Climate Change are irrefutable. There is a critical need to confront the fact that we have been destroying the world in which we live. So, as we approach COP 26 in Glasgow, it seems a good moment to reflect on how the countries of Asia are dealing with climate challenges.

In their report of November 2020, McKinsey analysts found that “with many low-lying coastal cities exposed to flood and typhoon risk, dramatic increases in heat and humidity expected across the region, and extreme precipitation forecast in some areas, but drought anticipated in others, Asian societies and economies will be increasingly vulnerable to climate risk without adaptation and mitigation”.

A recent article in the blog of the Asian Development Bank comments “Global climate change caused by human activities will continue to be catastrophic for humanity. Climate change is having serious impacts on the world’s water systems, and changes in these systems can have an enormous impact on people’s lives. This is because water plays a critical role in the very existence of all forms of life on earth as the foundation of human well-being and prosperity and a source of life and livelihoods. For example, without water, farmers could not grow crops or raise animals. In Asia, most of the climate change risks come down to water”.

The mass migration of people from sub-Saharan and North Africa is largely driven by climatic change such as flooding, drought and crop failure. Not to mention political threats and unsupportable economic pressures forcing them to seek a better life elsewhere. But their challenge is not unique. The pattern is repeated in South and Central America and parts of the Middle East.

So, in the face of this clear and present danger, what are some key countries in Asia doing? Indonesia is particularly vulnerable to climate change with its rapidly growing population especially in coastal areas, and strong dependence on natural resources for income generation and consumption. With its energy demand growing 7 percent annually, Indonesia must secure resources to achieve sustainable and inclusive economic growth.

In a survey of the countries most resilient to climate change, New Zealand was ranked highest globally followed closely by Singapore. What is the ASEAN group doing about climate change? Several member states have announced voluntary mitigation targets, including Indonesia targeting emission reduction of 26% from business-as-usual by 2020, which it believes can be increased to 41% with enhanced international assistance. Malaysia is also seeking a reduction of 40% in terms of energy intensity of GDP by 2020 compared to 2005.

Typhoons and floods are clearly becoming more intense and frequent as Vietnam and the rest of Southeast Asia bear the brunt of climate change.
At the Asia Scotland Institute we are working with the Indian Government with an event focused on Cleaning the Ganga. Experts will gather on November 8th in a round table discussion and exhibition being held at City of Glasgow College to consider what can be done and what has been achieved in recent years.

Still focusing on climate related issues, we will also be exploring environmental challenges and concerns around the Third Pole of the Tibetan Plateau, with the dramatic melting of ice and the diversion of water from the Himalayas.

We have to act before it is too late. Asia needs to lead the way. Together, we still just have time to achieve the goals needed to save the planet.

]]>
How a Taliban victory in Afghanistan has changed the geopolitical map https://asiascot.com/publications/how-a-taliban-victory-in-afghanistan-has-changed-the-geopolitical-map Fri, 10 Sep 2021 10:20:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=2103 Beyond the daily scenes of terrified Afghans striving to find a way through to the airport in Kabul as they seek a way out of the country, the significant longer-term issue that we need to be aware of is the changed geopolitical landscape of Central Asia.

How will the neighbouring countries around Afghanistan react to the Taliban government? What advantages will be seized that we need to be fully aware of? The back story contains plenty of indications of what is to come. When the US withdrew from the TPP a vacuum was created in Asia into which China moved. Afghanistan may prove similar. In a discussion with Rory Stewart, he pointed out that the country to a large extent has depended on foreign aid to run basic services, money which is now frozen. A solution to this problem for the Taliban lies in Beijing.

Rich in minerals and natural resources, including substantial reserves of lithium, the basic ingredient in electric-vehicle batteries, Afghanistan is a prime target for China and its ally Pakistan. The withdrawal of US and NATO forces leaves the door wide open for the Chinese to exploit an opportunity that would be of great benefit to their economy. This, combined with the chance to point to a major failure of American foreign policy, should enable them to cut a long-term deal that will secure their existing investment in the major copper mine at Mes Aynak.

A few weeks ago in late July, China’s foreign minister met Taliban leader Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar in China and signalled its willingness to do business. Yun Sun, Director of the China Programme at the Stimson Centre think tank wrote that the Chinese cannot believe that America walked away from this asset. Combined with its Belt and Road global initiative, China is likely to work with Pakistan on both their and Afghanistan’s infrastructure needs and open a route through Pakistan to gain access to Pakistani ports as a means of re-routing Chinese oil supplies.

Vanda Felbab-Brown of Brookings has highlighted China’s need to ensure that there is a secure border with Afghanistan. Although small, that border is close to Xinjian and China will need reassurance that a Taliban government does not allow an Islamic jihad to spread eastwards. Most importantly, China does not want to see Afghanistan become a base for the East Turkistan Islamic Front or other Uighur related groups.

The Pakistan military supported the rapid Taliban deployment, without which they could never have been so effective. Bruce Riedel of Brookings has said that the problem is that the US has little influence over Pakistan. A nuclear power, it is China’s closest ally providing a land route to the Persian Gulf. China has already signalled it will support a Taliban Afghanistan.

As this is written, both China and Russia are keeping their embassies open in Kabul as others withdraw. At the end of last year, China’s accumulated non-financial direct investment in Afghanistan totalled $630 million and total bilateral trade was $550 million.

The events of the past few weeks will prove to have been necessary from a domestic political perspective for President Joe Biden but be likely to have serious long-term economic and reputational consequences. Ryan Hass, another past Speaker at the Asia Scotland Institute, summarises this when he writes that while Chinese leaders are not enthusiastic about the Taliban takeover, they will not allow principle to stand in the way of pragmatism.

The geopolitical landscape has clearly become a great deal more complicated in this region of the world.

]]>
Fears that Afghanistan could slip into anarchy and civil war https://asiascot.com/publications/fears-that-afghanistan-could-slip-into-anarchy-and-civil-war Thu, 10 Jun 2021 07:11:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=2352 In late 2020 soldiers from 2nd Battalion, The Royal Regiment of Scotland deployed to Afghanistan for what is to be the beginning of the end of operations in this troubled country. They are part of a long line of brave Scottish soldiers serving in far flung Afghanistan.

The first foray by the British Army in Afghanistan ended badly when in January 1842 a column of 4,500 troops with around 12,000 camp followers began their retreat from Kabul. One by one the column was picked off by Afghan tribesmen until being all but destroyed at the Battle of Gandamak. The lone survivor was Dr William Brydon, of Scottish descent, who had studied at the University of Edinburgh. Our history in Afghanistan is a long and painful one.

Recently the Asia Scotland Institute, jointly with the Defence & Security Forum, held a virtual conference entitled The Future of Afghanistan. With the recent news of The United States bringing forward the date for the departure of its forces to mid-July, the webinar was designed to seek the views of three members of the Afghan National Assembly together with input from Brigadier Ben Barry, author of the recent book “Blood, Metal and Dust: How Victory Turned into Defeat in Afghanistan and Iraq”.

It was clear from the attendees dialling in from all over the world, that there was a shared concern that Afghanistan could slip into anarchy and civil war.

After two decades of fighting, prospects for a peaceful transition appear poor. There is a seeming inability of the central Kabul-based government to operate effectively in the different provinces where local officials, often Taliban, hold much greater sway. This affects attempts to implement a coordinated national economic and security policy as acknowledged by the members of the Afghan National Assembly.

Ben Barry confirmed that military resources were almost certainly not up to the task required and the contracts to service and upgrade ground and air assets left a considerable gap between what is available and what is needed.

Of great concern is the plight of women in the country, many of whom have become educated and assumed significant roles within the economy. Naheed Farid is MP for Herat and Chair of the Human Rights, Civil Society and Women’s Affairs Commission where she is a vocal champion for Afghanistan’s women. She has expressed concerns for the future of women and girls under a Taliban controlled regime with all the gains of broader emancipation and empowerment being destroyed.

Both Presidents Obama and Trump increased US intervention in the face of the rising risk from ISIS. This helped reduce the influence of ISIS but failed to shift the balance in favour of government forces. Mir Haider Afzaly MP, representing the people of Kapisa and Chairman of the Defence Commission, was very clear on the weaknesses of Afghan National Defence Forces, leaving journalists and government officials exposed. A view also shared by Haji Ajmal Rahmani.

Over the winter of 2020 and 2021 a campaign of assassination was waged in Kabul and other cities, targeting members of the judiciary, government administration and media, with a significant number of working women attacked.

So, how to move forward? Over the course of this long conflict dozens of Scottish servicemen and women have been killed or severely injured leaving many of us wondering if it was all worthwhile. The outcome in the next few weeks will determine the extent to which we have influenced events. I fear that history will not treat us kindly.

]]>
The United States can still regain its position in leading the free world https://asiascot.com/publications/the-united-states-can-still-regain-its-position-in-leading-the-free-world Thu, 25 Feb 2021 08:17:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=2357 When I last wrote in these columns on concerns in Asia about the US Presidential Elections it was when the results were being questioned and many living in Asian countries could be forgiven for wondering if Western democracies could claim the best and purest form of governance. It is now only a few weeks later and the world has watched in astonishment how the supporters of Donald Trump stormed the Capitol building on 6 January, triggering a second Impeachment trial.

As I write from the US, the impact of events is possibly even greater with 24-hour coverage of President Biden’s actions to implement his administration’s plans to address the Covid, climate and economic crises faced by families and businesses in the face of political opposition as he tries to build consensus and cross-party support. The unrest in the streets of Russia and Myanmar has been greeted with condemnation from the West but generated the inevitable response that America has lost the moral high ground to criticise others.

A statement from the Myanmar military leadership just after the coup sounded strikingly similar to Donald Trump’s claims of a rigged election on 3 November. They wrote that there was terrible fraud in the voter list during the democratic election which runs contrary to ensuring a stable democracy and added that unless this problem is resolved, it will obstruct the path to democracy. In the face of condemnation from many in the West, the view that they expressed questioned the right of the United States to criticise, especially given the events of 6 January.

This image of the kettle calling the pot black, the hypocrisy of an apparent failure of the democratic process in the United States has been repeated. Putin was quick to point out the moral weakness of President Biden, although interestingly not of Trump. In China, the response to the US raising the protests in Hong Kong and their treatment of the Uighurs was predictably the same. Iran, of course, is not the same and the Biden administration is committed to re-establishing America’s global leadership in controlling the coronavirus pandemic and asserting moral credibility by halting the sale of arms that prolong the suffering in Yemen. Indeed, the difference in the quality of those filling the new cabinet posts is tangible and in short the message is that the US is returning to its global leadership role.

It is not too late for the United States to regain its position in leading the free world but certainly, those In the ASEAN group and other parts of Asia seem clear in their hope that the void being filled by China over the past four years is retaken by America and its allies.

In Japan, India and Taiwan the hope is that trade and other ties will strengthen and grow in 2021 with the US and other western nations pursuing links in a post-pandemic world. This includes Scotland embracing opportunities with parts of the world where the Scots were so influential in the past and still have unique skills in financial services, alternative technology and the kudos that will come with hosting the COP 26 conference in Glasgow in November of this year.

]]>
How will Asia view US election? https://asiascot.com/publications/how-will-asia-view-us-election Tue, 05 Jan 2021 07:00:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=4554 As we have watched the drama that has been the US presidential election of 2020 play out on television and in the press, how is this seen by others?


Even in Scotland where we are used to the rough and tumble of parliament in Holyrood and Westminster, the highly litigious nature of the American process has been cause for alarm – the extraordinary and continuing denial by those who lost that Joe Biden had won. We can wonder what on earth happened to the original constitution drawn up by the founding fathers, some of whom were Scotsmen, headed by James Wilson and John Witherspoon

If the events of the past few months have puzzled or even alarmed us, imagine how they have been viewed by others around the world, and especially in Asia. Those living in autocratic countries who might have aspired to a more democratic way of life looked in vain for what President Ronald Reagan had described in his farewell speech in 1989 as the Shining City Upon a Hill, drawing on a speech of John Winthrop from 1630.

With its system almost in a public meltdown under the stress of its own presidential election, how do people overseas see what’s happening there? And how will it affect America’s standing going forward?

John Sudworth of the BBC writes “It is not Chinese authoritarianism but Western democracy that suddenly seems to be facing a crisis of legitimacy. The world’s freest and wealthiest economy, once thought to be so much better placed to fight the virus with the tools of transparency and accountability, has fallen well short.” The same might be said of the highly divisive presidential elections and the anger and hatred that so many feel about the results.

“It’s too soon to know the extent to which a new president and new policies can turn around America’s battered image, but a change like this has happened previously. Barack Obama’s policies weren’t uniformly popular over the course of his presidency, but people generally saw his approach to world affairs as more multilateralist than Bush’s, and ratings for the US remained relatively high in most nations throughout his tenure” writes Richard Wilkes.

This could soon change, however. Biden respects multilateralism and a rules-based international system. He believes that America should lead by example. Against a backdrop of a global pandemic, working with the World Health Organisation to prevent infection and boosting the race to implement Covid-19 vaccines will send positive signals, writes Fonteh Akum

Joe Biden’s victory saves the Japanese government some disappointment. Over the past few years, Tokyo’s diplomatic efforts were bolstered by the personal relationship between former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and President Donald Trump. However, no one in the current Japanese government is capable of working with President Trump in the same way. The election result forestalls that conundrum, says Yasushi Kudo

Indeed, it’s time our countries explore alliances and institutions and agreements that are not centered on the US. We can no longer rely on the US to protect our interests – be it in terms of global health, trade, climate, or security. It was naive of us to think they ever could.

Winston Churchill wrote of the Americans that “they will always do the right thing, only after they have tried everything else”. We can only hope that the US’s leadership of the free world will be restored and the bridges rebuilt with allies and trading partners. Perhaps it is not too late for this to be the wake-up call so badly needed and for relationships to be rebuilt across Asia.

]]>
Let’s offer a home to Hong Kong’s hard-working people https://asiascot.com/publications/lets-offer-a-home-to-hong-kongs-hard-working-people Tue, 06 Oct 2020 10:01:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=4569 Scots led the way in building successful businesses in Hong Kong. Now we should renew our economic edge by attracting entrepreneurs from Hong Kong to Scotland.


Asian entrepreneurs have had a significant impact on other economies through their work ethic and energy. At the Asia Scotland Institute our mission is to increase understanding of pan-Asia and to educate and inspire Tomorrow’s Leaders to reconnect with the indomitable spirit that carried their forebears overseas.

Professionals from Asia could have a huge effect on the UK economy. It has already started. The House of Commons Home Affairs Committee found that over 50 percent of our Chinese population was under 30, including doctors, solicitors, architects, bankers, stockbrokers, business executives, teachers and university lecturers.

In 1989 there was an initiative to create a ‘Hong Kong in the Highlands’ to provide a safe haven for Hong Kong’s 3.2 million British passport holders following the 1997 handover. In his report A Home for Enterprise, Fife researcher Douglas Mason argued that Scotland would be a particularly appropriate home for them, given its economic and racial openness. The small island of Colonsay, population 124, showed a keen interest in the idea and said: ”Very interesting. Tell us more”.

Just a year ago, the Adam Smith Institute revisited the idea in a report called Doing our Duty by Hong Kong, arguing that under the handover agreement, the UK is responsible for upholding the rights of Hong Kong citizens until 2047. “We should offer them British National (Overseas) status,” said the author Matt Kilcoyne, “with full residency rights in the UK—just as we did for the Ugandan Asians in the 1960s and 1970s. While the UK is far away, we have a special link to Hong Kong, and the ability to offer a home away from home should the need arise”.

Tony Leung, with the Young Scottish Chinese Professionals network, lives in Edinburgh and arrived in Scotland from Hong Kong nearly fifty years ago. “Attracting those with professional qualifications and skills would be a very good idea. I have found Scotland to be a very welcoming place and open business community”. affairs and status in the EU and the world. Consider this as a transition period before an island or a new purpose-built town like Milton Keynes is created. I feel that this is an opportunity for Scotland more than to Hong Kong people”.

The UK government accepted Kilcoyne’s idea but hedged it with all sorts of qualifications. BN(O)s could come, but only for two years. Their right to remain would be considered only after that: i.e. it might never happen—and someone having to return to Hong Kong would not be very popular with the Hong Kong authorities. They would be better off in other countries that would make them a better deal.

Asia is very entrepreneurial on many fronts, and ahead of the UK in many industries. Asians could bring an important new perspective on how we do things, and on what we do, and that would invigorate commerce. It might boost several initiatives—AI, driverless cars, clean energy, fintech etc. —that HMG wants to make us a world leader in. So, I cannot see what there is to lose.

Boris Johnson has promised ten Freeports in the United Kingdom. Might he designate a Freeport area specifically for HK migrants? Interesting prospect.

As we emerge from the Covid 19 pandemic and consider the desperate need to put the UK back on its feet, consider the particular case of Scotland and how, through thoughtful leveraging of its historic links, we could benefit from the sensible integration of a community or communities of hard-working immigrants from Hong Kong.

]]>
Effects and the city – society is being changed rapidly by urban individualism https://asiascot.com/publications/effects-and-the-city-society-is-being-changed-rapidly-by-urban-individualism Tue, 07 Jan 2020 11:08:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=4557 Just before St Andrew’s Day, Lord Stephen Green, former chairman of HSBC and now chairman of the Natural History Museum in London and Asia House visited Scotland as the guest of the Asia Scotland Institute.


In two talks at the Business School of Strathclyde University and in Edinburgh he led an attentive audience through the themes of his recently published book, The Human ­Odyssey – East, West and the Search for ­Universal Values.

Enormously topical as we ­wrestle with global challenges, not least of which is the vital importance of understanding each other, he ­highlighted the key issues affecting current and future generations of Scots.

The long human odyssey of self-discovery has now reached a ­crucial stage – everything we do affects ­everyone and everything else – and we know it. The next 100 years will bring more change than we can ­easily imagine, more opportunities for more people to achieve the fulfilment of a good life and more risk of catastrophe and harm to the whole planet than we have ever known before.

All the greatest challenges of the next 100 years will centre on Eurasia – the landmass which includes Europe, Asia and the Middle East and which is the largest and most crowded ­continent on the planet. We are used to thinking of Europe and Asia as two separate continents but there is no geographical reason for this. Eurasia is a single land mass, and we cannot make sense of its present and future without understanding that its past has been woven together for a long period of time.

It is where all the world’s great living cultures first emerged. It is increasingly closely connected, physically and virtually. China has taken its place on the world stage and, indeed, all the world’s great powers of the 21st century are Eurasian, except one – America. All are inextricably entangled there, including America. Human experience in Eurasia is becoming, for better or worse, more and more intensively shared. Because of its sheer scale and ­complexity, what happens in Eurasia will affect the whole world.

Most Eurasians now live in cities – by the end of this century, virtually all will do so. Everywhere, our societies are being changed utterly by the transient life of the city. In the midst of the change it is easy to lose sight of just how radical, how fast and how recent this change is. ­However, the common experience of connected urban life has not produced any emerging sense of common purpose – let alone of shared identity. On the contrary, the cultures of ­Eurasia – each with its own traditions, ­histories, memories, beliefs and aspirations – are becoming more, not less, assertive as they jostle together. Throughout much of Eurasia – with only the Europeans as exceptions – the consciousness of nationhood is at least as strong as ever. Digital connectivity, far from making old histories fade and old barriers crumble, seems to nourish these cultural identities as never before.

So a new balance of power – based on the same fundamental principles that determined relations amongst the European powers in the 19th ­century – is coming into being, only this time on a Eurasian stage. In the 22nd century there may well be other great powers on the world stage: but not yet. The new geopolitical order of this century is a Eurasian one. It is subject to the same sorts of stress as the old Europe was – in particular, one established global power (America) feels challenged by a big new ­rising power (China). Does this mean that they will inevitably clash? Will the next spiral of history remind us of the terrible 100 years in Europe which finally ended only in 1989?

But if this seems like a familiar ­pattern of history, something else is occurring which is not. For better or worse, the experience of urban life is changing all those cultures of ­Eurasia.

Humanity is slowly but surely discovering that the breakdown and disappearance of older pre-urban social structures and the broadening knowledge horizons of city life mean that we are gradually becoming more individual and more plural. There is no possibility of reversing this trend in human experience, because there is no possibility of reversing the trend of urbanisation. No culture, however deeply rooted, will remain immune to this change.

Viewed geopolitically, the main question is whether and how the world views of the two most important and influential powers on the Eurasian stage – China and America (the one fundamentally Confucian, the other essentially individualist) – can be constructively synthesised. At a deeper level, though, the great question is how the irreversible fact of urbanisation will nurture the growth of human individuality in every society, such that the wisdom of others transforms and enriches all those great Eurasian cultures. All the risks and possibilities for our ­grandchildren depend on how these questions are answered.

As we consider this the Century of Asia and try to figure out how best to engage with it, Lord Green’s observations are helpful and relevant. A former minister of state for trade and investment, he is also, uniquely, an ordained minister in the Anglican Church whose earlier books have included Serving God? Serving Mammon and Good Value: Choosing a Better Life in Business. His ­messages resonate with those of the Asia Scotland Institute to educate and inspire tomorrow’s leaders in Scotland.

]]>
Will the US and China fall into the trap of war? https://asiascot.com/publications/will-the-us-and-china-fall-into-the-trap-of-war Thu, 03 Oct 2019 10:14:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=4572 Some of your readers will have heard of the ­Thucydides Trap, but for those who have not, it may have an ­application in the increasingly tense relations between the United States and China, as the latter appears to represent a growing challenge to the former in global markets on the 70th anniversary of the creation of ­modern China.


The Thucydides Trap refers to a ­situation where one great power threatens to displace another and war is almost always the result, although it does not always have to be. Graham Allison, the American political scientist and professor at the John F. Kennedy School of ­Government at Harvard and author of Destined for War. Can America and China Escape the Thucydides Trap? writes, “as China challenges America’s predominance, ­misunderstandings about each ­other’s actions and intentions could lead them into a deadly trap first identified by the ancient Greek historian Thucydides. As he explained: “It was the rise of Athens and the fear that this instilled in ­Sparta that made war inevitable.” The past 500 years have seen 16 cases in which a rising power threatened to displace a ruling one. Twelve of these ended in war.

How does the trap affect China and the US? Viewed from one perspective there appears to be a seemingly unstoppable China rising to displace the United States – an extraordinary reversal of the 1978 situation where 90 per cent of Chinese people were surviving on under $2 a day and now only 1 per cent are. The trap is, as Henry Kissinger said, a way to look through the news and noise of today to understand what is happening.

There may need to be an event to trigger conflict. North Korea could be the provocateur or a violent intervention in Hong Kong or Taiwan in the way that the assassination in Sarajevo started the chain of events leading to the First World War.

What are the causes of the current situation and can they be reversed? What does the current trade war with China initiated by the US administration hope to achieve? Is it the reversal of China’s seemingly unstoppable growth? Is it the protection of American manufacturing and other jobs? Is it an attempt to prevent intellectual property theft?

Wendy Cutler, vice-president of the Asia Society Policy Institute was ­previously acting deputy US trade representative. She recently noted that fresh negotiations which will include not just ministerial-level meetings, but ongoing discussions at the vice-ministerial level are heartening. She said: “I think what would be extremely helpful now is for both sides to quiet down and let the negotiators do their work – if China and the US can establish a better atmosphere in the coming months”. However, as I write, the US administration has just threatened to stop Chinese companies listing on the NYSE and NASDAQ.

Failure to resolve these and ­other issues will probably exacerbate the trend of China challenging the hegemony of the United States

China has several challenges to tackle and its ability to do so will accelerate its growth and potential threat to displace the United States. Right now, the US economy is the ­biggest in the world. It produces roughly $20 trillion worth of goods and services every year. China ­produces about $13 trillion worth of goods, so it’s still a bit behind.

George Magnus, previously senior economic advisor at UBS Investment Bank and now research associate and author at the China Centre, Oxford University, doesn’t entirely agree with this spreadsheet approach. “It is fair to say that there is an adversarial relationship between the US and China that did not exist before Xi ­­Jinping and that after his ascendancy in succession to Hu Jintao there was a material change as he initiated his China Dream. China became more ideological and assertive. If China can grow its economy at 5 or 6 per cent for the next ten to 20 years against growth of 2 to 3 per cent in the US, at some time between 2027 and 2032 China’s GDP will be bigger – although Chinese income per capita will be only 15 to 20 per cent of the US.”

Finally, some factors to consider. The steps being taken by the US to curb and curtail China are understandable but the Trump administration’ significant ceding of influence has been a major contributing factor to the dangers of the trap.

First, withdrawal from the Trans Pacific Partnership has effectively opened the way for China to increase its economic leverage in the region. Second, China’s Belt and Road initiative has started to tie ­countries into a network model that China first used for domestic purposes in ­opening its western provinces. Third Donald Trump’s renunciation of the Paris Climate Accord handed China the chance to assume a leadership role, as Xi laid out in his Davos speech, and lost the US a great deal of moral leadership. Finally, the whole tone in the US of decrying globalisation and amplifying the importance of nationhood and self-interest first has been its theme at the recent United Nations General Assembly.

Add the above to the growing ­concerns over impeachment of Trump in the US, and a feeling that traditional laws and norms are being breached or ignored, and one sees a weakened power with disjointed and distracted leadership, a great deal more vulnerable to the trap that Thucydides wrote of nearly 2,500 years ago, challenged by a rising China with an autocratic governance system and centrally planned economy.

We shall see where it all ends – to quote Napoleon Bonaparte: “Let China sleep, for when she wakes, she will move mountains. Let her sleep for when she wakes, she will shake the world”.

Or, in the words of an Asian ­saying: “You have the watches, but we have the time”.

]]>
Is this the end of the Anglosphere? https://asiascot.com/publications/is-this-the-end-of-the-anglosphere Thu, 15 Aug 2019 10:11:00 +0000 https://asiascot.com/?p=4560 Where does this ­summer leave us? Viewed from a hot and humid ­United States, where I find myself ­sipping an iced latte (a position of cool perspective), the challenges facing the UK and this country bear many similarities.


August has brought tension and uncertainty. The so-called ‘special relationship’ may seem increasingly dysfunctional, but as summer moves to ‘fall’ we can at least try to agree on the key issues that are troubling many, especially younger citizens.

The tragic shootings in El Paso and Dayton bear the hallmarks of the hate-filled messages oozing from President Trump, magnified further by social media and the onslaught of 24-hour news, scratching for an angle. This posturing rhetoric is mirrored in the UK by increasingly intense clashes over European ­membership and what a divided ­Britain supposedly stands for.

Adding to this is the growing ­concern in global markets on the effects of the US/China trade war and the ratcheting up of actions on both sides. This will begin to impact on the way in which Scotland and the rest of the UK can seek to engage with Asia and build bridges and understanding; a central feature of the mission of the Asia Scotland Institute.

Where are UK/US relations now? John Micklethwait, editor-in-chief at Bloomberg News, writing a few months ago, said: “Look around the Western world. Which country’s politics seem the most shambolic?

“In the past, your eyes might have headed instinctively toward southern Europe. The politicians in ­Athens, Madrid and Rome are ­certainly ­trying hard, but if you want dysfunctionality, there are only two places to go: Washington and London. ­America’s government was shut for a long stretch of this year — and now President Trump is stuck in a row with Congress over whether or not there is a national emergency on the southern border of the United States. Britain’s government is meandering toward Brexit with all the discipline of a drunk on an icy road. If nothing changes, the United Kingdom will topple out of the European Union at the end of October.

“Is this the end of ‘the Anglosphere’? For nearly four decades, America and Britain have touted the benefits of open markets, globalisation and personal freedom. Now that voice has either shrunk to a murmur or is singing a very different tune.

“It is not silent yet, but the faltering partnership that has set the mood music for much of the world is something that matters far beyond the English-speaking world. Everybody who cares about liberty and the rule of law should pray for them to be heard.”

The tone for Brexit continues to evolve to the point of deafening alarm with Boris Johnson’s appointment as Prime Minister. Meanwhile, President Trump pumps up the ­volume in his dealings with China coupled with the lack of clear narrative for the handling of foreign policy issues. Crises are piling up and the impression is that UK diplomats lack the bandwidth, backbone and resources to deal with them – Iran, Hong Kong, Afghanistan, Kashmir and elsewhere.

A recent Gallup Report surveyed the subjects most concerning to voters on both sides of the Atlantic. Those listed highest were healthcare, the economy, immigration, climate change, Russian interference and misuse of data. Little else is left. New revelations on the role of ­Cambridge Analytica and others in the US election and Brexit referendum also ­continue to appear. The film The Great Hack recently described ­Alexander Nix and Brittany Kaiser’s part in deceiving the British voter and promoting fake information in the run-up to the US elections. Now, Dominic Cummings, the great architect of the deceptive Leave campaign, has indeed taken back control and holds a key role in Boris Johnson’s team. ­People vs Politicians? I think we know the answer.

These are elements that add to a growing conviction on either side of the Atlantic that the public were somehow misled. The resultant tensions in society have combined to fuel racial and other reactions that have spilled over into violence and growing division. Indeed, both the US and the UK are seeing potentially disastrous events unfolding. The Trump administration’s trade policies are prompting increasingly hard reactions from China with talk of stopping all agricultural goods imports from the US and a reduction in the value of the yuan against the dollar. The likelihood of a no-deal Brexit has started to further weaken the pound on international markets. There is talk of recession. Anger, uncertainty and a growing number of unresolved issues combine with a divided and toxic society in both countries.

But it doesn’t all need to be doom and gloom. The Asia Scotland Institute was founded to increase understanding of pan-Asia by Scots and educate and inspire tomorrow’s leaders. Scotland and its people have a long history of making a difference both in the Americas and Asia, whether Andrew Carnegie in the United States, William Glover in Japan or Patrick Geddes in India. We can only hope that ­connections with Asian markets improve and that as the world pivots increasingly to the East, tomorrow’s leaders in Scotland are able to identify and pursue opportunities there.

Our speakers in the coming months will be expected to educate and illuminate the situations we currently face and the opportunities they may bring. We look forward to seeing you there.

]]>